I'm shopping for a new healthcare plan for my middle-class family of 5. Most plans on the marketplace won't work for us.

My husband was unemployed and we qualified for government health insurance, which covered emergency care and removed worry about deductibles. After that plan ended, I joined a healthshare that costs $518 a month and requires a $1,000 per-incident deductible. Two days after joining, my daughter broke her collarbone; we paid X-rays and urgent care out of pocket until meeting the deductible, then received $1,000 reimbursement for physical therapy. Because healthshares lack legal regulation like insurance, I began previewing healthcare.gov plans for 2026. Marketplace premiums ranged from $271 to $677, and a silver HMO showed a $0 family deductible but a high out-of-pocket maximum; subsidies appeared inapplicable to our household.

"For the first time in my adult life, I didn't worry about meeting deductibles for broken bones, surgeries, or other emergencies. The plan covered everything. I felt an invisible weight lift off my shoulders. As Murphy's Law would have it, I only used this plan a few times for primary care visits and to get my children's dental cleanings. But two days after ending the plan and joining a healthshare, my daughter broke her collarbone."

"After entering my family's information (married, three dependents) and our income, the site populated three tiers: bronze, silver, and gold, with premiums ranging from $271 to $677 a month. At first glance, it all looked promising. I hovered over a Silver Elite Saver Plus HMO plan, priced at $590.32 a month. It offered a $0 family deductible (except for a $400 drug deductible) and a $18,200 family out-of-pocket maximum. Primary care visits were $60, specialists' visits were $100, and ER visits were covered at 50%."

Read at Business Insider