"The first thing our taster noticed when they tried this slice was the impressive (and not in a good way) amount of cheese globbed on top. While some cheese is warranted on pizza, too much makes the bite cheese-centric and ruins the experience. The crust, while adequate in flavor, was chewy, and combined with the greasy cheese and thin pepperoni, our taster got a slice that was wholly out of balance."
"Reddit users aren't afraid to make jokes about the quality of Papa Johns pizza. Another labeled it 'Cardboard with sauce [and] garlic butter' and said it was only marginally above frozen and Costco pizza (to which a third Reddit user said, 'Don't you insult Costco pizza like that')."
"Papa Johns is JUNK food pizza. It has its place late at night after many drinks, twice a year max."
A taste test comparison of six major chain restaurant pepperoni pizzas ranked Papa Johns at the bottom. The primary issues identified were an excessive amount of cheese that overwhelmed the slice, a chewy crust despite adequate flavor, and thin pepperoni that created an unbalanced overall experience. While the pizza may satisfy a greasy craving, it falls short of quality standards. Reddit users have expressed similar criticisms, comparing it unfavorably to frozen and Costco pizza, though some acknowledge its niche appeal as late-night drunk food consumed only occasionally.
Read at Tasting Table
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]