"The four cookie flavors were inspired by the variety of the Subway Series sandwiches, and were the Subway Cookie Club, The MexiCali, The Monster, and The Great Pickle. Each creation featured a footlong cookie base, along with drizzles and toppings. They were only tested out in Miami for one day at a pop-up restaurant called Cookieway, which coincided with Subway's first unveiling of its footlong chocolate chip cookie for National Cookie Day that year."
"It's not clear if they were ever meant to be released nationally, but they certainly were interesting creations. The Subway Cookie Club was a double chocolate cookie with vanilla frosting, that got topped with chocolate chips, sprinkles, chocolate and raspberry sauce, and shark-fin-like chunks of macadamia and raspberry cheesecake cookies perched on top. The Subway footlong cookie creations got progressively more interesting, or just stranger, from there."
Subway introduced a footlong cookie in 2024 as part of a Footlong Collection with churros and pretzels; the cookie remains on most menus. Four experimental footlong cookie flavors were tested in 2022 at a one-day Miami pop-up called Cookieway. The flavors were the Subway Cookie Club, The MexiCali, The Monster, and The Great Pickle, each built on a footlong cookie base with drizzles and toppings. The Subway Cookie Club combined double chocolate, vanilla frosting, chocolate chips, sprinkles, sauces, and macadamia-raspberry cheesecake chunks. The MexiCali paired a sugar-cookie base with dulce de leche, white chocolate, espresso elements, mole, Tajin, and corn nuts.
Read at Tasting Table
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]