"It's an incredibly tricky question, one that has vexed philosophers (and science-fiction writers) for generations. And before Alien: Earth, it's a question raised mainly just in passing in the Alien movies. There's some idle speculation in the films about where the Xenomorphs sit on the evolutionary ladder, and nearly every Alien story at some point deals with the question of whether synthetic creations care about their makers. Ridley Scott's divisive"
"Still, in Alien: Earth,Noah Hawley more explicitly explores some of the ideas that have just been hinted at in Alien before. You could contend (and I'd concede your point) that Hawley is too clumsy in the way that he raises Alien 'ssubtext to the surface. In this week's episode, "The Fly," there are times where the conversations aren't just artlessly blunt but also sloppily wedged in, as though Hawley were rushing to clarify a few major themes before the season's big finish."
Alien: Earth examines what constitutes sentience more explicitly than earlier franchise entries, focusing on creator-created relationships and synthetic care. Conversations can feel blunt or hastily inserted, yet they provoke challenging ideas about evolution, godlike creators, and artificial beings. The series pairs philosophical dialogue with intense, disgusting, and frightening imagery, delivering some of its most viscerally effective moments. Kirsh provides sharp, brainy exchanges, including an 'onion' metaphor and a rebuke about limiting a being with star-exploring potential. Themes include synthetic autonomy, the placement of Xenomorphs on an evolutionary ladder, and humanity's origins influenced by alien forces.
Read at Vulture
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]