British MPs face Hobson's Choice for restoration of the crumbling, unsafe Palace of Westminster

"The first, dubbed Full Decant, would see the site fully emptied, with the Lords and the Commons moving to new premises for most of the works. The second, Enhanced Maintenance and Improvement Plus (EMI+), would see only the House of Lords move out for part of the project and construction otherwise undertaken around MPs' daily work. According to these proposals, the latter have until 2030 to choose which option to go for. During that time, companies will bid for construction contracts, the palace will seek planning consent, and a phase of early, preparatory works will begin."

"To his mind, the choice between the two options was a "no-brainer": "The decant saves between £10-24bn and 30 years," he said. "I would suggest that it's a no-brainer that a full decant is needed." And, he added, "I don't think it's satisfactory to take that decision in 2030, because what all projects need is certainty.""

"Fellow speaker Nick Smith MP, who chairs the House of Commons Administration Committee, said the Commons would be debating these costed proposals "in the coming weeks". Taxpayers currently foot a £1.5m weekly bill simply to maintain and repair the building reactively. The cost for the full programme of works ranges from £11.5b"

The Palace of Westminster faces urgent restoration needs after years of warnings about its condition. A joint parliamentary committee submitted two costed options: Full Decant and EMI+. Full Decant would fully empty the site, moving the Lords and Commons to new premises for most works. EMI+ would move only the House of Lords out for part of the project, with construction carried out around MPs’ daily work. The choice is currently scheduled to be made by 2030, with planning consent, contract bidding, and early preparatory works beginning before then. Jack Pringle argues Full Decant saves between £10–24 billion and 30 years and should not be decided in 2030 because projects require certainty. Nick Smith MP said the Commons will debate the proposals in the coming weeks.

Read at The Art Newspaper - International art news and events